Sign It and It Won’t Run

Since ORF 3.0, we sign every ORF binaries with Vamsoft’s Authenticode code signing certificate. This is great, because you can be sure that you have the original files from Vamsoft and no tampering was made with them. This practice is also encouraged by Microsoft and signed components probably will be a requirement for the Windows ‘Longhorn’ Server Certification Logo program.

When we released the Vamsoft Image Spam Agent extension for ORF, we signed the agent imgspamagent.exe binary as usually and let it go. Then we started receiving reports about timeouts running the agent and we did not have any idea why only specific servers were failing to run the agent and why the agent worked when they tried running it from command-line. And we were struggling to find an explanation until one of our clients (thanks!) found that the agent tries to connect to every time it starts. Cool.

I mean, uh? Pardon me?

Obviously, the timeout was caused by the security settings of the affected servers—these servers blocked HTTP access to, thus the timeout error. But what makes the agent trying to visit VeriSign if we did not add such code to it?

Here is the trick: Windows was checking the Certificate Revocation List (CRL) of VeriSign to make sure that our certificate was not revoked, e.g. because our certificate was compromised and now bad people are trying to impersonate Vamsoft. The funny thing is that Windows does not check the CRL for regular ORF binaries, because they were written in Delphi, but the agent was written in .NET/C# and .NET programs behave differently.

According to this blog entry, if your .NET assembly is signed using Authenticode, every time the assembly is loaded, Windows performs the Certificate Revocation List check (depending on the user settings). This potentially means a couple of seconds wait to get your .NET program started or even more if the firewall prevents the program from accessing the CRL.

Now we know. If you sign it, it won’t run.

3 thoughts on “Sign It and It Won’t Run

  1. Pingback: La billeterie » Blog Archive » Sign It and It Won’t Run !

  2. Pingback: Vamsoft Insider » So what is “vamsoft.exe”?

  3. Pingback: verisign logo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

AlphaOmega Captcha Classica  –  Enter Security Code